An Empirical Comparison of Spatial Scan Statistics for Outbreak Detection


Expectation-based scan statistics extend the traditional spatial scan statistic approach by using historical data to infer the expected counts for each spatial location, then detecting regions with higher than expected counts. Here we consider five recently proposed expectation-based statistics: the expectation-based Poisson (EBP), expectation-based Gaussian (EBG), population-based Poisson (PBP), populationbased Gaussian (PBG), and robust Bernoulli-Poisson (RBP) methods. We also consider five different time series analysis methods used to predict the expected counts (including the Holt-Winters method and moving averages optionally adjusted for day of week and seasonality), giving a total of 25 methods to compare. All of these methods are detailed in the full paper.



We present a systematic empirical comparison of five recently proposed expectation-based scan statistics, in order to determine which methods are most successful for which spatial disease surveillance tasks.

Primary Topic Areas: 
Original Publication Year: 
Event/Publication Date: 
September, 2005

September 20, 2018

Contact Us


288 Grove Street, Box 203
Braintree, MA 02184
(617) 779 0880

This Knowledge Repository is made possible through the activities of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Cooperative Agreement/Grant #1 NU500E000098-01, National Surveillance Program Community of Practice (NSSP-CoP): Strengthening Health Surveillance Capabilities Nationwide, which is in the interest of public health.

Site created by Fusani Applications